Carr says news distortion policy will stay as Gomez calls for a public interest rulemaking
Weekly insights on the technology, production and business decisions shaping media and broadcast. Free to access. Independent coverage. Unsubscribe anytime.
The FCC’s November open meeting on Thursday had no broadcast items on the agenda. Instead, broadcast regulation came up in the press conferences afterward, where Chairman Brendan Carr said the agency’s news distortion policy would remain in force and Commissioner Anna Gomez called on the commission to define the public interest standard it applies to broadcasters.
The commission voted on five items, including jamming contraband phones in prisons, drone spectrum, telephone numbering security, relay service compensation and satellite earth stations. Carr then answered reporters’ questions about polling, the Disney license review, and Danielle Thumann Severs, his advisor who has been nominated to the commission.
Carr said the FCC is not reviewing any specific poll or broadcast of a poll. He made clear, though, that the policy behind his pre-election warnings to broadcasters is staying in place.
“What we were doing there was we were reminding all broadcasters and stakeholders that there is an FCC doctrine in place, the news distortion policy. And if you violate the news distortion policy in a way that involves polls, then that’s a problem,” said Carr.
“On my watch, it’s going to stay there as best I can tell at this point,” Carr added.
Gomez, the commission’s only Democrat, used her press conference to argue for limits on the agency’s authority over broadcasters.
“Broadcasters serve communities on the public’s airwaves, and they should be held to a clear standard. But the currently undefined standard can be easily abused, which is why the Commission should open a rulemaking, offer identifiable constraints on its own authority and let the public weigh in,” said Gomez.
Polls, the midterms and Disney
Carr was asked whether the midterm results would change how the commission reviews media companies. He opened his answer with a reference to the election.
“People gave me a hard time for suggesting that there were some fake polls out there, but I think I’ve been proved to be correct,” said Carr.
He then appeared to treat the remark as a joke, saying to “scrub that from the chairman’s dinner remarks.” After that, he gave his answer on the news distortion policy.
Carr said a decision on whether to begin a license revocation proceeding against Disney does not depend on a pending court ruling. The comment period in that review closed three months ago.
“No new update for you on that. We’re continuing to review all the filings and all the pleadings there, and we’ll move forward when we feel like the record and the facts sort of justify a next step one way or the other,” said Carr.
Thumann nomination and the media docket
Sen. Ben Ray Luján has said documents released under the Freedom of Information Act show Thumann worked on media matters, which she told the Senate Commerce Committee she had not done. FCC spokespeople have said Luján mischaracterized the documents.
Carr said Thumann’s work touched media only on issues that cut across bureaus.
“If there’s cross-cutting issues, whether it’s reg fees or EEO discrimination, those are cross-cutting issues that a lot of people work at. But in terms of the silo of media issues, things like the national cap, the quad, equal time issues, early renewal issues, that’s not stuff that my wireline advisor works on,” said Carr.
He described the challenge to Thumann’s integrity as “a very different form of politics” from criticism of his own policy decisions. He also pointed out that she “had fewer no votes getting out of committee than I did.”
Luján had also said Thumann reviewed a draft of the commitment letter Skydance planned to submit in the Paramount merger proceeding. Carr said FCC staff take part in that kind of review as a matter of course.
“The FCC processes many, many transactions, and there’s always a discussion that takes place about conditions that are going to be filed. There’s discussions that routinely take place about commitments that people are going to make, and that type of commitments that company makes and the process that goes through is routine at the agency,” said Carr.
He added that there was “no deviation from standard FCC practice.”
Asked whether it matters that a Democrat sits on the commission when the president’s party holds the majority, Carr said the statute bars more than three commissioners from one party and leaves the rest of the decision to the president and the Senate. He also reflected on his own time in the minority.
“I thought I brought really good perspective to the agency when I was in the minority. I wish that view prevailed more than it did, but it’s okay,” said Carr.
Gomez on oversight and consolidation
Gomez described the meeting as the commission’s first since “a historic midterm election.” She laid out four areas where she said the agency should change course: affordability programs such as Lifeline and E-Rate, a defined public interest standard for broadcasters, transparency in how companies are added to the covered list and a move away from what she called “culture war fights.”
Gomez said the commission’s actions on broadcasters should be a priority for congressional oversight.
“As I’ve said, I would really like us to define what we mean by the public interest. That is not a vague, amorphous standard that basically just means you violated it, you say something this administration doesn’t like,” said Gomez.
She also asked Congress to look at media ownership.
“We are seeing a massive wave of consolidation, not just in the media context, although certainly things Congress oversight over the actions that we’ve taken to permit so much consolidation of the media would be really terrific,” said Gomez.
Gomez said she has not had any conversations about being removed from the commission. That possibility has been raised again because another commissioner could be confirmed before the December meeting.
“What I know is that this has been rumored now for a year and a half, maybe, and yet I’m still here. And I would like to continue to be here,” said Gomez.
She said her term expired in July and that she can serve until the end of next year.
What the commission adopted
The commission approved all five agenda items.
Votes were unanimous except on the contraband phone item. That order allows departments of corrections and their contractors to seek FCC authorization for radio frequency jamming inside correctional facilities. Gomez approved in part and dissented in part over whether incarcerated people’s families could be charged for jamming costs through calling rates.
The commission also opened the 450 MHz band to drone command-and-control links. It allowed ground-based drone detection radar in the 24 GHz band and revised power measurement rules in the 800 MHz air-ground band. The remaining actions added national security certifications for VoIP direct access to telephone numbers, opened a review of telecommunications relay service compensation and allowed non-geostationary earth stations in motion across the full 28.35-28.6 GHz band.
An item on reforming the high-cost universal service program was adopted on circulation and removed from the agenda. The next open meeting is Dec. 17.





tags
Anna Gomez, Brendan Carr, Danielle Thumann Severs, FCC
categories
Broadcast Business News, Heroes, Policy