Appeals court questions Nexstar’s effort to limit restrictions on Tegna merger
Weekly insights on the technology, production and business decisions shaping media and broadcast. Free to access. Independent coverage. Unsubscribe anytime.
A federal appeals court panel expressed skepticism Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, about Nexstar Media Group’s attempt to narrow a court order preventing it from integrating operations with Tegna, raising questions about whether the broadcaster can move forward with portions of its $6.2 billion acquisition while an antitrust lawsuit proceeds.
During oral arguments before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Pasadena, California, three judges questioned whether limiting the restrictions to television stations in markets where Nexstar and Tegna overlap would adequately address the competition concerns raised by DirecTV and 13 state attorneys general.
The legal battle has left one of the largest transactions in local television history in limbo, despite the Federal Communications Commission approving the acquisition and Nexstar formally closing the deal in March 2026.
The merger would give Nexstar a combined television station portfolio reaching approximately 80% of U.S. households, substantially expanding the company’s position in the local broadcasting industry.
DirecTV and the states filed lawsuits March 18, 2026, alleging the acquisition violates federal antitrust laws. Nexstar completed the transaction the following day, but a federal judge subsequently ordered the companies to maintain separate operations while the litigation proceeds.
A preliminary injunction issued in April 2026 prevents Nexstar from further integrating Tegna’s operations into its existing station group. Although Tegna shareholders have received payment and the company’s stock no longer trades publicly, its business remains operationally separate from Nexstar.
Nexstar attorney Deanne Maynard argued Tuesday that the injunction should be limited to stations in 31 television markets where the two companies have overlapping operations.
Maynard maintained that holding certain stations separate while allowing other portions of a transaction to proceed is an established approach in broadcast merger cases.
However, judges Marsha Berzon, Johnnie Rawlinson and Xavier Rodriguez repeatedly questioned whether the appeals court should modify the lower court’s order without a more detailed assessment of how such an arrangement would work.
Berzon expressed concern about the appellate court substituting its judgment for that of the district court, which had already considered the practical challenges of separating portions of the combined broadcasting companies.
“My major concern here is that we’re an appellate court,” Berzon said, according to Deadline. She questioned whether the panel could confidently determine that a narrower restriction would be workable.
Rodriguez suggested that the issue might be better addressed by returning the matter to the lower court rather than having the appeals panel determine the appropriate scope of the injunction.
“Why do we have to decide anything now?” Rodriguez asked.
Attorneys representing DirecTV and the states opposed Nexstar’s proposal, arguing that the acquisition must be evaluated as a single transaction rather than as a collection of individual station purchases.
Emily Curran of the California Department of Justice said isolating the overlapping stations would not adequately restore the competition that existed before the merger.
She argued that Tegna had operated as a successful, independent broadcasting company before the acquisition and that maintaining its separation was necessary while the antitrust claims were considered.
DirecTV attorney Ben Horwich similarly rejected the suggestion that the plaintiffs or the courts should be responsible for restructuring Nexstar’s acquisition to make it legally acceptable.
Horwich pointed to previous unsuccessful broadcast mergers, including Sinclair Broadcast Group’s proposed acquisition of Tribune Media and Standard General’s attempted purchase of Tegna, as examples of transactions that failed amid regulatory and competition concerns.
He also questioned whether separating a relatively small group of stations would be consistent with Nexstar’s stated business strategy of achieving greater scale and operational efficiencies.
The dispute has significant implications for Nexstar’s plans to consolidate operations, reduce expenses and realize financial benefits from the acquisition.
According to Deadline, Nexstar shares have declined approximately 10% during the eight months since the transaction became entangled in litigation.
The continued separation of the two companies also prevents Nexstar from fully implementing the operational changes that typically follow a major broadcast acquisition, including combining certain corporate functions and pursuing cost savings across the enlarged station portfolio.
The appeals court took the matter under advisement following Tuesday’s arguments. A decision is expected in early 2027, although the judges did not announce a specific timetable.
If the panel rejects Nexstar’s appeal, the company could seek reconsideration by a larger group of 9th Circuit judges or ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case.
The underlying antitrust lawsuit is scheduled to go to trial July 6, 2027, in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California.
The appellate proceedings concern the restrictions currently preventing the companies from combining operations, rather than a final determination of whether the acquisition violates antitrust law.




tags
directv, Lawsuits, Mergers and Acquisitions, Nexstar Media Group, Nexstar-Tegna Merger, Tegna
categories
Broadcast Business News, Featured, Local News, Policy